NFL Draft Day Buzz: Giants Eyeing Abdul Carter, Shedeur Sanders

Giants Poised to Select Edge Rusher Abdul Carter at No. 3

As the 2025 NFL Draft commences, the New York Giants are expected to select Penn State edge rusher Abdul Carter with the third overall pick. Carter, a Philadelphia native, has been lauded for his elite pass-rushing abilities, drawing comparisons to NFL stars like Von Miller. His transition from linebacker to edge rusher in 2024 showcased his versatility and explosive play, culminating in a season with double-digit sacks and recognition as the Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year. ​

Evaluating Carter’s Fit in the Giants’ Defensive Scheme

The Giants‘ defense, under the guidance of head coach Brian Daboll, is anticipated to benefit significantly from Carter’s addition. His ability to disrupt opposing offenses aligns with the team’s strategy to bolster their pass rush. While the Giants already have talent on the defensive line, Carter’s presence could elevate the unit’s performance, potentially making other players like Kayvon Thibodeaux expendable.

Internal Debates: Daboll’s Preference for Jaxson Dart

Despite the consensus on selecting Carter, internal discussions within the Giants’ organization reveal differing opinions on quarterback prospects. Head coach Brian Daboll reportedly favors Jaxson Dart from Ole Miss over Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders. Daboll’s preference is influenced by Dart’s mobility and composure under pressure, traits that align with his offensive philosophy.

Shedeur Sanders: A Polarizing Quarterback Prospect

Shedeur Sanders, son of NFL legend Deion Sanders, is one of the most discussed quarterbacks in this draft. His tenure at Colorado showcased his leadership and passing accuracy, completing 71.8% of his passes for 7,364 yards and 64 touchdowns. However, concerns about his tendency to hold onto the ball too long and his high sack rate have been points of contention among scouts. ​

Giants’ Strategy: Trading Back into the First Round

With the No. 3 pick likely used on Carter, the Giants are exploring options to trade back into the first round to secure a quarterback. Potential trade partners include teams like the Los Angeles Rams or Detroit Lions. The Giants hold multiple picks in the top 105, providing them with the assets to maneuver within the draft.

Owner John Mara’s Influence on Draft Decisions

Owner John Mara’s past regrets, particularly the decision to pass on Micah Parsons in 2021, may influence the team’s current draft strategy. Mara’s desire to avoid repeating past mistakes could sway the Giants to make bold moves, such as trading up to secure a preferred quarterback prospect. ​

Assessing Jaxson Dart’s Potential in the NFL

Jaxson Dart has demonstrated significant growth at Ole Miss, showcasing his ability to lead and adapt. His performance has caught the attention of several NFL teams, with the Giants considering him a viable option to develop under veteran quarterbacks like Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston. Dart’s skill set is seen as a good fit for Daboll’s offensive system. ​

Shedeur Sanders’ Draft Stock and Potential Landing Spots

While Sanders is a top-tier talent, his draft stock has seen fluctuations. Some mock drafts project him going as high as ninth overall, while others suggest he might fall to the late first round. Teams like the New Orleans Saints have shown interest, and the Giants are monitoring his availability closely. ​

Giants’ Quarterback Room: A Blend of Experience and Potential

The Giants’ current quarterback roster includes seasoned veterans Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston. Adding a young quarterback like Dart or Sanders would provide the team with a developmental prospect who can learn under experienced mentors, ensuring a smooth transition for the franchise’s future signal-caller. ​

Conclusion: Giants’ Draft Decisions to Shape Franchise’s Future

The 2025 NFL Draft presents the New York Giants with pivotal decisions that will shape the team’s trajectory. Selecting Abdul Carter at No. 3 addresses immediate defensive needs, while trading back into the first round for a quarterback like Jaxson Dart or Shedeur Sanders could secure the team’s long-term success. The choices made during this draft will reflect the organization’s commitment to building a competitive and resilient team for the future.